Challenging SF/F Books That Are Worth The Effort To Read

Modérateurs : Estelle Hamelin, Eric, jerome, Jean, Travis, Charlotte, tom, marie.m

Répondre
Avatar du membre
marie.m
Messages : 6884
Enregistré le : lun. avr. 11, 2011 9:37 am

Challenging SF/F Books That Are Worth The Effort To Read

Message par marie.m » mer. mai 11, 2011 10:51 am

Suite à l'article de Ranker, faisant état de cinq livres plutôt difficile à lire mais qu'il faut lire néanmoins, SF Signal a posé la même question à plusieurs auteurs de science-fiction et de fantasy.
Voici le début de la réponse de Jeff VanderMeer :
"Challenging" usually is code for "yeah, I'm calling you 'challenging' rather than 'visionary' or 'brilliant' because I really don't want my mind cross-pollinated with crazy-ass stuff that will change my life forever--just give me some escapist cotton candy." So here goes...your brain will be transformed. "The Beak Doctor" by Eric Basso, a novella that's Gothic by way of James Joyce and Proust, rewards more than one read. In fact, you'll have to read it more than once to get the sense of it and its ruminations on a strange disease. It's one of those let-it-wash-over-you and come back later for the logic of it. Any of Reza Negarestani's half-philosophy/essay, half-fiction tales, featured in part in the Starry Wisdom anthology, should be required reading.
Pour lire l'ensemble des réponses, c'est sur le site de SF Signal.

Avatar du membre
bormandg
Messages : 11906
Enregistré le : lun. févr. 12, 2007 2:56 pm
Localisation : Vanves (300 m de Paris)
Contact :

Message par bormandg » mer. mai 11, 2011 12:11 pm

A remarquer la citation n° 5 de John C Wright....
World of Null-A was savaged by science fiction's earliest and best known professional critic of the genre, Damon Knight, who pushed the work into undeserved obscurity, perhaps because he preferred the type of works written, or, rather, committed, by poseurs and artistes such as I mention with scorn above. Mr. Knight dismissed the paradigm-shifting technique of plot-weaving as mere sleight of hand. But perhaps it not as easy as it looks to juggle all the pieces of a jigsaw in midair, forming one picture to the reader, and then, by flipping one more bit of the puzzle into view, to both change the whole picture of what has gone before, and have the picture make sense; and then to do it again. The scientific process itself is nothing other than this juggling of jigsawwork to create successively more elegant and accurate pictures of the cosmos: to dismiss it in art is to overlook it's significance in life. Others have attempted the Vanvogtian style of paradigm-shifting, either successfully, as with The Paradox Men by Charles L. Harness, or unsuccessfully, as with Mr. Knight's own deservedly forgotten Beyond the Barrier, a work that serves as a living reminder that those who cannot perform a tricky technique of art at even an apprentice level should not mock it as a mere trick.

The book and its sequel, Players of Null-A may not be in print, but they are worth seeking out, if for no other reason than to undo an injustice perpetrated by Mr. Knight. I have heard a rumor that some obscure midlist author wrote an authorized sequel to the work, but I doubt that author's skill is equal in general to the masterful work of A.E. van Vogt, or specifically to this, his masterwork.
:wink:
"If there is anything that can divert the land of my birth from its current stampede into the Stone Age, it is the widespread dissemination of the thoughts and perceptions that Robert Heinlein has been selling as entertainment since 1939."

Répondre

Retourner vers « Les infos sur la Science Fiction, la Fantasy et le fantastique en général »